Gumroad vs. Payhip: Which Platform Is Best for Selling Digital Products in 2025?
Whether you're selling ebooks, Notion templates, digital planners, or AI-generated tools, the right platform can save you time, boost your income, and protect your privacy. In this comparison, I’ll break down the pros, cons, features, and fees of Gumroad vs. Payhip so you can choose the one that fits your faceless business best.
Quick Comparison: Gumroad vs. Payhip
| Feature | Gumroad | Payhip |
|---|---|---|
| Free Plan | Yes (with 10% fee) | Yes (5% fee or monthly plans) |
| Custom Domain | Not available | Yes (even on free plan) |
| Checkout Experience | Simple, fast | Customizable with upsells |
| Product Types | Digital, memberships, courses | Digital, courses, coaching, subscriptions |
| Email Marketing | Basic broadcasts | More built-in automation |
| Payout Frequency | Every Friday | Instant via PayPal/Stripe |
Verdict: Both are solid platforms, but your choice depends on your goals. Let’s dive deeper.
Who Is Gumroad Best For?
Gumroad is perfect if you want to launch quickly with minimal setup. It's clean, simple, and ideal for:
- Creators selling ebooks, PDFs, or simple downloads
- Those who want to avoid monthly fees (10% cut per sale instead)
- Minimalists who don’t need heavy customization
Pros:
- Fast product uploads and delivery
- Easy checkout process (no login required)
- EU VAT handled automatically
Cons:
- No custom domain support
- Basic storefront customization
- Limited email tools
If you’re building a faceless brand and just want a frictionless way to deliver digital products without much overhead, Gumroad gets the job done.
Who Is Payhip Best For?
Payhip shines for creators who want more control over their store appearance, marketing tools, and checkout flow.
- Best for those who want a branded storefront (with your own domain)
- Ideal if you're selling bundles, courses, or recurring subscriptions
- Helpful if you want built-in affiliate or upsell options
Pros:
- Custom domain + white-labeled store
- Built-in email marketing + customer tagging
- Flexible pricing tiers (free or flat monthly)
Cons:
- Slight learning curve for setup
- Still takes a 5% fee on free plan (unless upgraded)
If you’re building out a serious faceless brand, Payhip may be the better long-term play—especially if you're layering in multiple product types, subscriptions, or email flows.
Fee Breakdown (Updated for 2025)
- Gumroad: 10% flat fee on all sales (no monthly plan)
- Payhip:
- Free plan – 5% fee per transaction
- Plus plan – $29/mo, 2% fee
- Pro plan – $99/mo, 0% fee
Tip: If you’re making under $500/month, the free plans are great. Once you scale, Payhip’s paid tiers become more cost-effective.
Which Platform Is Better for Faceless Creators?
Let’s be real—when you’re running an anonymous or semi-anonymous brand, simplicity, security, and automation matter most. Here’s the faceless-friendly verdict:
- Use Gumroad if: You want a fast, simple setup with minimal effort. Great for beginners or single-product creators.
- Use Payhip if: You want more control, a branded experience, and scalable features like upsells and email automation.
Both are solid. But Payhip is a better choice if your brand is growing, and you want to build a more customized, white-label feel while staying anonymous.
Final Thoughts: Gumroad vs. Payhip
You can succeed with either platform. The key is picking the one that fits your workflow, content type, and long-term vision.
My advice: Start with Gumroad if you’re launching your first product. Move to Payhip when you're ready to scale and customize more.
No matter which you choose, both platforms let you:
- Sell digital products without showing your face
- Collect payments securely
- Automate delivery and customer follow-up
And that’s a win for any faceless creator building a brand on their own terms.
More Tools for Faceless Creators:
- Explore all tools & tutorials
- How to Set Up Your First Digital Product
- Join the newsletter for faceless creator tips + tool comparisons every week
Comments
Post a Comment